I welcome fall kicking and screaming. I love summer and actually enjoy fall, but I know fall portends of winter. Fall is a season I used to love, but as I get older, the grumpy old lady comes out in me. I hate, in no particular order, the cold (especially when there is a bitter wind when I walk to work), the difficult of driving in snow, and the astronomical amount of money I spend on fuel oil.
However a Manhattan is a heavier drink with richer, more complex flavors and it is why I don’t hate the colder nights coming on. It warms you going down and lingers with a strong finish. If your only experience with Manhattans comes from pre-mixed bottles of it from your youth or from ordering it at your local sports bar, please give it a second chance. The Manhattan is a drink that really needs quality ingredients to shine. And a bad one isn’t worth drinking.
A Manhattan is made with three ingredients, either rye or bourbon, sweet vermouth and bitters. The choice between rye or bourbon is a personal one. And while I wouldn’t use my good sipping $80-a–bottle, Whistlepig rye in a Manhattan, I have used 10 year ryes in my Manhattans, and I will tell you why. As opposed to whiskey sours in which the lemon juice and simple syrup have such a strong presence and obscure the nuances of a high-end aged whiskey, Manhattans are very balanced with the individual flavors shining through. Now, that said, use what you have, I mostly make mine with a $25-$30 bottle of rye or bourbon and am very happy. (For those looking for some advice on where to start, I recommend Redemption or Rittenhouse rye and Buffalo Trace or Eagle Rare bourbon). But here is what I will also tell you, my very favorite, top-of-the-line cocktail bars use Old Overholt as their house rye. It is cheap, but their drinks are amazingly good, so don’t let price keep you from buying a bottle of rye. For well under $20, get Old Overholt for your mixed drinks.
Sweet vermouth, however, I have a very strong opinion about, and for me, it makes or breaks the cocktail. Antica Carpano is an imported Italian sweet vermouth. It is definitely WAY more expensive than the cheap ones you will find at your average liquor store. I am blessed with an amazing liquor store with people who really know cocktails. When I went to buy my first bottle, “Nate” told me Antica Carpano was the only way to go and he promised, at $40 for a liter bottle it would be well worth it. It is a sweet vermouth that you can also drink as an aperitif while you are cooking dinner, by throwing it in a wine glass with ice, a splash of soda and an orange twist. An $8 bottle of sweet vermouth would never be drank straight, take my word for it. The good news is that it will last you for quite a while.
The bitters are where the fun/creative part of Manhattan’s comes in. Everyone has heard of Angostura bitters, and they are fine in the Manhattan. But if you want to elevate your Manhattan to an ethereal plane, buy orange bitters. And even within orange bitters there is variation. And if you do a side-by-side comparison of Manhattans made with Reagan’s orange bitters to Manhattans made with Fee Brother’s orange bitters, you will definitely note a difference. Reagan’s has more “bitter” to it, while Fee Brother’s has more orange flavor. I have read recently about vanilla bitters, and if I can get my hands on some, I promise you, I will test it out and see if it is as delicious with vanilla bitters as it seems it would be.
The last important thing you need is a good sized swath of orange peel for a garnish. Use a vegetable peeler and peel a good sized wide piece, being sure to avoid as much of the white pith as possible. Take a sip of your Manhattan before you twist the orange rind over the drink, and then after you have given it a good twist to spray a light layer of orange oil over the top of your drink.
Okay without further ado/lecturing here is the recipe:
Fill a shaker or jar partway with ice
2 ounces of rye or bourbon
1 ounce of sweet vermouth
3 dashes of orange bitters
Shake vigorously and strain into a coupe glass, martini glass, (small wine glass, whatever you’ve got!)
Twist a good-sized swath of orange peel over top of the drink and then use as a garnish.